Accidental Abortion: Use Of Methotrexate For Misdiagnosed Ectopic Pregnancies - Better Health
I received the two comments below from readers and use this opportunity of their tragic experiences to revisit a concern that I raised about two years ago regarding methotrexate therapy for the presumptive diagnosis of ectopic pregnancy….
I was told I had an ectopic pregnancy and was advised I was in need of a Methotrexate shot. I got it. One week later my hormone level was continuing to rise. Low and behold 4 days later my ultrasound showed I was carrying twins. The Dr. s had presumed ectopic too early. Getting the shot caused me to loose Twin A and to give birth to a very much underweight 28 weeker. This experience has changed my life forever. My son fought to survive he continues to today now 13 months old. I would hope anyone who is told they have an ectopic pregnancy would be cautious when it comes to this shot. Yes I agree it helps if your life is in danger due to an ectopic pregnancy. Just take time to ensure there is no doubt that s what it is. My Dr couldn t see the baby so assumed ectopic, however carrying twins like I was you’re not able to see as early as a single pregnancy. My son is paying everyday because of my mistake and doing as one Dr. said make sure you have more than one confirmation, it could cost you a perfectly healthy baby in the end. Fri Jun 19, 05:45:00 PM 2009
Anonymous said Hi can someone help me? My husband and I were trying for a baby and I fell pregnant (good news). I started having a few brown spotting and slight cramping which I was advised by my GP to go to the hospital for a scan. Whilst there I had many tests and the doctors thought it might be ectopic and said he was going to keep me in for a few days to monitor my blood levels. I had a scan but being only five weeks it was hard to say. I was referred to another doctor on the ward and he told me it was ectopic. I trusted his knowledge and he said he needed to give me methotrexate now as it was Friday so the pharmacy would be shut. I was shocked but agreed of course. 3 days later I was told the baby is still alive and is in my womb. My blood levels increased after 3 days and then decreased from 7000 to 6000 on the 7 days. How long will it take to lose my baby as it’s hard to know its alive? Fri Jul 03, 11:15:00 AM 2009
Ever since methotrexate became popular for treating ectopic pregnancies, I have seen the unfortunate scenario reported by our readers above played out time and time again. Methotrexate (MTX) is an analog of folic acid. It binds tightly to an enzyme called dihydrofolate reductase and when it does so, interferes with the production of tetrahydrofolates. In the end, this interferes with the normal production and repair of DNA by limiting the production of a key nucleotide, thymidine. Other metabolic effects are also known, but the take home message is that MTX can result in lethal damage to cells that are replicating, particularly those that are replicating rapidly, like certain cancer cells.
Because of its documented efficacy in the treatment of malignant trophoblastic cells (choriocarcinoma), MTX has been employed in recent years as an alternative to surgical therapy in selected cases of ectopic pregnancy (Lipscomb, et al. NEJM 2000;343:1325-29). Ectopic pregnancies, by definition, implant ‘outside the uterus’ with more than 95% occurring in the fallopian tubes and about 2.5% in the cornua of the uterus (where the fallopian tubes enter the uterus). For that reason, they are frequently referred to as ‘tubal pregnancies,’ although they can also occur in the cervix, ovary and intra-abdominally. The fallopian tubes cannot restrict the growth of invasive placental tissues, as can the endometrium, and they certainly cannot accommodate a growing embryo beyond a certain point before they rupture and hemorrhage. Indeed, ectopic pregnancies can be quite deadly if not treated appropriately. They are still a major cause of maternal mortality, accounting for 10-15% of all maternal deaths, and they are the leading cause of death in pregnant women in the first trimester. A ruptured ectopic pregnancy is a true medical emergency.
Because of the rising incidence of ectopic pregnancy, the risk (maternal and medical-legal) of not identifying and treating an ectopic pregnancy in a timely fashion, and the widespread acceptance and success of MTX therapy as an alternative to surgical management of an ectopic pregnancy if caught early enough, there has been a coincident increase in the inadvertent use of MTX in unrecognized early intrauterine pregnancies. The usual scenario is one in which the pregnancy is not quite as far along as anticipated and the patient happens to present with complaints of abdominal pain or some spotting and no clear intrauterine pregnancy is identified by ultrasound. The ‘absence’ of an intrauterine pregnancy can be misdiagnosed because the pregnancy really is too early, but in at least one of the scenarios above was more likely the result of the inexperience of the individual(s) performing the ultrasound study.
This situation can be especially confusing if the pregnancy hormone levels (hCG) appear to be low for the expected gestational age based on last menstrual period (as is often seen in women who ovulate later, and hence conceive later, in their cycles) or if a woman has a tender adnexal mass because a hemorrhagic corpus luteum (intraovarian bleeding at the site from which the egg was ‘hatched’) or torsion of an adnexal mass (rare this early in pregnancy) which might be very difficult to differentiate from an ectopic pregnancy.
Since MTX is a category X drug, known to be teratogenic in humans, it is important to ascertain the presence of an ectopic pregnancy rather than simply to use it empirically. Unfortunately, its inadvertent use with an intrauterine pregnancy is most likely to occur during the time of neural tube and very early cardiac development, both of which rely on folate-dependent pathways. Various algorithms are in place that employ ultrasound imaging, quantitative hCG levels, and progesterone levels to differentiate abnormal from potentially normal pregnancies and these protocols can be useful in minimizing the chance of the inadvertent use of MTX and also in directing its use when appropriate for the management of an ectopic pregnancy. Perhaps the greatest risk of ectopic pregnancy is not suspecting that one could be present. Patients who are adequately counseled and followed closely are much less likely to end up in emergency situations.
To our readers above, I am SO SORRY for both of you. This is a failing of the medical system and is a growing concern of mine due to the ready accessibility and simplicity of use of methotrexate (and also another drug, misoprostol, that is used in the medical evacuation of the uterus when an inevitable miscarriage is suspected).
My feeling is that it should never be used in an asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic patient until either an ectopic pregnancy is seen, no intrauterine pregnancy is documented (by a competent sonographer) at hCG levels where an intrauterine pregnancy should readily be visible, the patient has significant risk factors for an ectopic pregnancy (e.g., previous ectopic, known history of pelvic inflammatory disease or tubal reconstructive surgery) or when there are well-documented abnormalities in the rise of hCG that are highly suggestive of an ectopic pregnancy. My heart goes out to both of you.
This post, Accidental Abortion: Use Of Methotrexate For Misdiagnosed Ectopic Pregnancies, was originally published on Healthine.com by Kenneth Trofatter, M.D., Ph.D.. Tags: Accidental Abortion, Ectopic Pregnancy, Methotrexate, Obstetrics And Gynecology, Radiology, Ultrasound You may also like these posts The Amazing Coincidence That Brought A Physician And Patient Together Across The Country When Bison Attack: Wild Injuries In Rehab Hospitals Buffalo Carpaccio Doctors: It s Not What You Say, But How You Say It Living La Vida Locum: 10 Tips For Being A Terrific Traveling Physician Medicaid Rates So Low, Hospitals Consider It Charity Care Read comments Comments are closed.
Return to article Search for: Latest Tweets from @DrVal Better Health Audio Featured Audio Healthy VisionTM with Dr. Val: Safe Contact Lens Wear and Care More Healthy Vision Segments UV Protection Driving in the Dark See all Better Health audio » --> Better Health Video Featured video The Unexpected Benefits of Locum Tenens Jobs More Recent video Paul Ryan s Take On Healthcare Reform The Primal Games: My Life Outside The Comfort Zone The Year In Review: Social Media Medical Stories See all Better Health video Newsletter Signup Get the Better Health Newsletter Email Address
Customize the content delivered to your inbox. Find out how The Better Health Network Our Bloggers Our Network Val Jones, M.D. Founder Follow on Twitter More [+]Less [-] Blogger Biographies Best new medical blog 2007 Signatory Member Volunteer History of Vaccines Google Ad S1 Advertisement Google Ad S2 Advertisement Google Ad S3 Advertisement Google Ad S4 Advertisement Google Ad S5 Advertisement Latest Interviews IDEA Labs: Medical Students Take The Lead In Healthcare Innovation
It’s no secret that doctors are disappointed with the way that the U.S. healthcare system is evolving. Most feel helpless about improving their work conditions or solving technical problems in patient care. Fortunately one young medical student was undeterred by the mountain of disappointment carried by his senior clinician mentors
I am proud to be a part of the American Resident Project an initiative that promotes the writing of medical students residents and new physicians as they explore ideas for transforming American health care delivery. I recently had the opportunity to interview three of the writing fellows about how to
Book Review: Is Empathy Learned By Faking It Till It s Real? I m often asked to do book reviews on my blog and I rarely agree to them. This is because it takes me a long time to read a book and then if I don t enjoy it I figure the author would rather me remain silent than publish my Read more
The Spirit Of The Place: Samuel Shem s New Book May Depress You When I was in medical school I read Samuel Shem s House Of God as a right of passage. At the time I found it to be a cynical yet eerily accurate portrayal of the underbelly of academic medicine. I gained comfort from its gallows humor and it made me Read more
Eat To Save Your Life: Another Half-True Diet Book I am hesitant to review diet books because they are so often a tangled mess of fact and fiction. Teasing out their truth from falsehood is about as exhausting as delousing a long-haired elementary school student. However after being approached by the authors’ PR agency with the promise of a Read more See all book reviews Commented - Most Popular Articles Why Would Any Doctor Accept Medicaid? 53 comment(s) Confronting Scandalous Physician Behavior: The Annals Of Internal Medicine Takes The First Step 26 comment(s) Low-Dose Naltrexone: Medical Revolution Or Pseudoscience? 14 comment(s) Abnormal Mammograms Often Terrify Women Unneccesarily 13 comment(s) The Decade s Top 5 Threats To Science In Medicine 11 comment(s) A Primary Care Provider s Dilemma: The Decision to Opt Out of Medicare 10 comment(s) Is Chris Matthews Mean? 9 comment(s) Mission Impossible: Getting A Medical License In California 8 comment(s) Fecal Transplants: Getting To The Bottom Of The Matter 7 comment(s) Bruised Finger Nails: How Do You Treat Them? 6 comment(s) Grand Rounds --> Better Health Channels
Better Health | Health Policy | Video | Audio | Interviews | News | Health Tips | Opinion | Book Reviews | True Stories Better Health Links
Ectopic Pregnancy: symptoms & treatments | Advanced OB-GYN Care
Tests for molar pregnancy | Cancer Research UK
Medical Mystery. I am showing as pregnant but negative tests | Wrong Planet Autism Community Forum
Ectopic Pregnancy Treatment/side Effects? - Mamapedia™